We had a pleasant stay at Rawayana Villas. I traveled with a group of 9, and we fit comfortably in the 4 bedroom villa with an extra bed. We enjoyed all getting to stay together, and the private pool was a huge perk. The bikes available on property were a fun addition as well. The staff was helpful and was responsive to any questions or problems that we had.
We weren't very impressed with the location. Rawai beach is about a 5 minute walk away, but it is a fishing beach only. It is a quieter area in Phuket, but wished that it would've been disclosed that you can't swim at Rawai. We found ourselves traveling to other beaches/cities most days to swim and eat.